Parag Pandya

Published · Updated

The $27 million lesson on regulatory risk

In 2024-25, Victoria's Essential Services Commission obtained civil penalties of more than $27.6 million against two energy retailers in the Supreme Court of Victoria. Everyone noticed the fines. The number that matters more to me is how many customers were affected. More than 730,000.

How many customers did the $27 million in fines cover?

Two cases make up the total.

Here is the maths.

Together, the fines work out to under $38 for each affected customer. That is why I look at the customer number first.

What is best offer messaging?

Most of those customers were affected by one thing. Origin failed to give adequate best offer messages to more than 655,000 customers. Sumo failed its best offer obligations for more than 60,000 customer accounts in 2022 and 2023.

In plain words, Victorian retailers have to tell you on your bill whether you are on the cheapest plan they offer for you. They have to do it at least every three months for electricity and every four months for gas. If you are not on it, the bill has to say how much you could save by switching.

When that message is missing or wrong, you might be told you are on the best plan when you are not. Nothing looks broken. You just keep paying more than you need to.

Why are quiet problems the bigger risk?

There were no blackouts and no cyberattacks. Just things that did not feel quite right. A bill that landed sooner than expected. A message saying you were on the best plan when you were not.

I call these quiet problems. They do not set off alarms, so they sit there until they turn into a fine. What usually broke down was a handoff. System to system, team to team, control to control.

Each team checks its own piece. The regulatory team writes down what the rule means. Product turns that into a feature. Engineering builds what the ticket says. Operations gets a process. Every one of those steps can pass its own test while a little of the rule is lost along the way, usually the awkward cases. Nobody owns the gap between two teams, so nobody is looking when something falls into it.

Are energy regulators getting tougher?

Yes, and not just in Victoria. In a speech at Australian Energy Week in June 2023, Australian Energy Regulator Chair Clare Savage said AER infringement notices and court penalties had passed $39 million over the previous two financial years. In the 14 financial years before that, the total was just over $3.5 million.

Maximum penalties went up in 2021. Before then, the largest court penalty for breaching the National Energy Retail Law was $1.5 million. Since 2021, the Federal Court has imposed penalties of up to $17 million.

What does a platform need to prove compliance?

Look at what the court ordered alongside the fines. Origin has to set up and maintain, for three years, a quality assurance process to check that best offer messages are actually going out on customer bills. Sumo was ordered to put a quality assurance system in place too.

That is the regulator saying it is not enough to have the feature. You have to show it worked, for every customer, every time.

Four things. A clear line from each obligation to the feature that meets it. A check that runs on every bill, not a sample, to confirm the message that should be there is there. An alert when something is missed, so you hear about it in days and not from the regulator in years. And evidence kept long enough to show an auditor what happened for any customer on any date.

What is the lesson for anyone rebuilding a utility platform?

If you are rebuilding a utility platform, make sure it can actually prove it is compliant, not just demo well.

Written by Parag Pandya, a Senior Product Manager in Melbourne with 18 years in Australian energy. Say hello on LinkedIn.

More writing

← All writing