Parag Pandya

Published · Updated

The reality of three hours of free electricity

"Three hours of free electricity every day"

For households, it sounded great. I read the government's consultation paper on the Solar Sharer offer to see how it would actually work, and it was more nuanced than the headline.

When the consultation paper came out I owned the Australian roadmap at Gentrack. If this became law, our retailer clients would have to bill it. So I read it as someone who would have to build it.

What is the Solar Sharer Offer?

The Solar Sharer Offer started on 1 July 2026 in NSW, south east Queensland and South Australia, the three regions covered by the Default Market Offer. Retailers with more than 1,000 customers in those regions have to offer at least one plan with a free three-hour window in the middle of the day:

Free use is capped at 24 kWh a day. It is opt in, you need a smart meter, and you do not need solar panels or a battery. Victoria is running its own version, called Midday Power Saver, from 1 October 2026.

How much can a household actually save?

The government's own analysis, published with the consultation outcome in January 2026, showed the benefit varies a lot depending on the household and how much use it can move into the window:

The top of that range assumes a pool pump and an EV you can charge at lunchtime. A household moving the dishwasher and the washing sits much lower.

What is the catch with network tariffs?

The networks do not have matching free tariffs, so retailers still pay network charges during the free window. They have to recover that somewhere, most likely through higher rates outside the window.

The Clean Energy Council's submission made the same point. The consultation paper itself said a free window had to be supported by changes to how networks set and charge tariffs. Network tariffs in many areas are still built around the late afternoon and evening peak. If they do not change, the cost can land on the people who cannot shift their use.

Is it actually the cheapest plan?

Here is the part the headline skipped. The Solar Sharer is a regulated plan priced against the Default Market Offer, and the default offer was never meant to be the cheapest price in the market. So a plan with three free hours can still cost more over a year than an ordinary market offer with no free hours at all.

The early numbers back that up. The Australian Energy Council's informal analysis found about 10,000 customers had signed up across the three regions, and some retailers tracking them found only about half were better off than on that retailer's best offer. Energy Consumers Australia modelled a home in the Ausgrid network using 20 kWh a day, against a specific market plan. With 30 percent of its power in the free window and 40 percent in the evening peak, it came out about $320 a year worse off on the Solar Sharer. With only 20 percent of its use in the evening peak, the same household came out about $210 a year better off.

What happened when it started?

SolarQuotes reported that Engie, Red Energy, Origin, Dodo, OVO and Sumo all put Solar Sharer plans forward, while EnergyAustralia missed the 1 July start. Some customers reported daily supply charges rising by more than 85 percent, across electricity plans generally and not only Solar Sharer ones, and the Energy Minister asked the energy regulator and the ACCC to look into retailers that raised supply charges.

Who should sign up?

It suits households that can genuinely move use into the middle of the day, such as people at home during the day, or anyone who can run the dishwasher, washing machine, hot water or EV charging on a timer. CHOICE warns you could end up worse off.

Do not choose a plan because part of it is free. Compare the whole year, supply charge included, against the cheapest market offer you can get.

Is the Solar Sharer good policy?

Good intention, wrong design. Free power in the middle of the day is the right idea. But building it as a regulated plan priced off the default offer meant it launched more expensive than plans many people could already get. I think there were better ways to do this, and this one missed the mark.

Written by Parag Pandya, a Senior Product Manager in Melbourne with 18 years in Australian energy. Say hello on LinkedIn.

More writing

← All writing